|“||I did it again. It's not supposed to happen. Please. I need help. Can you help me?!||”|
Trey's mother died at some point early in his life, and he was left to be raised by his abusive father Samuel. Samuel was a poacher with a criminal record consisting of arrests for drug use and solicitation. He liked to bring Trey to drug dens and prostitution brothels that he would frequent. In the early morning hours of May 14, 1991, police raided a brothel and found the then-eight-year-old Trey in a bedroom with a naked prostitute who had molested him. Samuel was busy having sex with another prostitute in the next room. It is unclear whether Samuel or the naked prostitute involved were prosecuted as a result.
As an adult, Trey started taking multiple prescribed medications for anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and borderline personality disorder, all preconditions for sleepwalking. On February 7, 2017, Samuel died of a heart attack, prompting Trey to start killing men who reminded him of his father, starting in February or the beginning of March. However, unconsciously, that was not enough for him; as he succumbed to sleepwalking, he started tracking down the places Samuel frequented, which had now been renovated into up-and-coming suburban homes. There, he would kill any homeowners present.
In the Dark
After claiming four lives in about six weeks, Trey kills Bob Joplin while he is out in the woods poaching deer. The following night, a sleepwalking Trey goes to the residence of Mike Hood and lures him to the front door by knocking on the door. There, he stabs him in the heart, killing him. The next night, Trey, once again sleepwalking, goes to the residence of Jon Kreutzmann and Lyn Anastasio. As they both watch a horror movie, Trey knocks on the door and Jon answers it, believing him to be the pizza deliveryman. Trey kills him and then follows Lyn to the back door, cutting his foot on a piece of glass broken by Lyn in the process. Lyn is unable to escape the house and is killed by Trey. The following morning, Trey wakes up and notices the cut for the first time. He treats it and then takes his prescription medication. Afterward, Trey lies down on his bed and has a dream of him beating up his father, who is unaffected and merely laughs at him before grabbing him by the neck.
The following night, Trey sleepwalks to the residence of Paul McConnell and gets him to open his front door. Trey then stabs him in the chest, but the large Paul shrugs off the wound, overpowers him, and grabs his shotgun. However, they both get into a struggle and the gun goes off, waking Trey up. As Paul tries to clear a blockage in the gun, a surprised Trey flees. The next day, he returns home and notices blood on his shirt and torso. He proceeds to burn the shirt and other bloodied clothes in a furnace, while he washes the blood off his torso by taking a shower. While doing so, he flashes back to his father demanding him to open the door. Afterward, Trey watches a news report about his killings, which shocks him. He attempts to call his psychiatrist, but the receptionist tells him the doctor is unavailable and hangs up, which causes him to have a psychotic break. In an attempt to stop himself from hurting other innocent people, Trey locks away his rifle and knives, then locks himself in the house. He makes many attempts to stay awake but is ultimately unable to do so, and he has also forgotten one hunting knife that is not under lock and key.
The following night, Trey sleepwalks to the home of Janis Weir, armed with the knife. He breaks in, causing Janis to flee into the bathroom. Trey tracks her down and starts stabbing at the closed door, all the while believing he is stabbing his father. At the same time, the BAU show up and hold him at gunpoint. Trey turns in Rossi's direction and tries to kill him, but Stephen shoots at the chair with a shotgun to wake him up. Now conscious, he looks at the knife, drops it, and becomes shocked. Rossi asks him if he knows where he is; Trey looks around and prepares to say that he was molested in this very house, but stops midway into the sentence. Then, Trey realizes that he sleepwalked again and that it was not supposed to happen. He pleads for help, and Stephen replies that they will try to get him some. Afterward, Trey is handcuffed by Alvez, who tells him that he is being arrested for eight murders, which brings Trey to tears. Trey is last seen being taken away on a medical stretcher and is almost certainly institutionalized afterward.
Trey had two distinct M.O.s, which caused the BAU to initially believe two different, independent unsubs were at work. As such, they dubbed one series of murders the work of "The Woods Unsub", and the other as the work of "The Home Invasion Unsub". Trey's signature, the only thing in common between both sets of murders, was killing all of his victims with a single gunshot or stab wound directed to the heart.
- As the Woods Unsub, Trey would kill male poachers with a history of violent confrontations, who all reminded him of his father, during the daytime hours. He would follow them into the woods, position himself at a safe distance, and kill them by shooting them once with a scoped Winchester .30-06-caliber, single-action hunting rifle. He was always organized during these killings and made sure he never left behind any incriminating evidence since he never sleepwalked during those murders.
- As the Home Invasion Unsub, Trey, while sleepwalking, would enter a home in the middle of the night and stab the homeowner(s) to death with a hunting knife, believing he was stabbing his father instead. All of the homes he targeted were former drug dens or prostitution brothels that his father frequented. The first victims, all women, suffered from multiple stab wounds, but as he devolved, the victims suffered only one stab wound. The first victims were also killed in home invasions, but the later ones were lured to the front door after Trey unconsciously knocked on it the same way as his father did. During these killings, he was disorganized and more violent, which would increase as he went along due to the heightening seriousness of his sleepwalking.
The unsub is a sleepwalking serial killer aged in his 20s. His sleepwalking diagnosis is based on his surprisingly strong ability to ignore pain inflicted on his feet during the latest murders; this, plus the fact that this happened at night, can only be explained by conditions such as neuropathy or sleepwalking. Because he still had great aim, neuropathy of the limbs was ruled out. Additional contributing factors like depression, addiction, or obsessive-compulsive disorder could be keeping his brain from reaching full REM sleep. Due to these sleepwalking episodes, he will wake up more tired than when he went to bed. These nighttime murders are his way of looking for some kind of release that he is not getting whenever he kills while awake. He is able to control his rage when he is awake, thus explaining the organized and calculated murders in the woods. That self-control turns off once he falls asleep, however, thus leading to the messy and chaotic home invasion murders.
Trey has some similarities to the prolific South African serial killer Cedric Maake and may have been indirectly based on him. Maake had three different M.O.s that he used simultaneously: bludgeoning passers-by at a beach with a rock; ambushing couples in cars, shooting the man before raping the woman; and killing tailors in their shops with a hammer. While the first two series of murders were soon identified as the work of a single killer, the third one was believed to be a different case almost until Maake's arrest, much like how Trey was initially assumed to be two independent serial killers.
- Ron Carini (shot)
- Jerry Hornsby (shot like the previous victim)
- March 14: Reba Wilson (stabbed seven times in the torso and arms)
- March 17: Pearl Roberts (stabbed nine times in the stomach, upper chest, and arms)
- March 18:
- Bob Joplin (shot)
- Mike Hood (stabbed once in the heart)
- March 19: Jon Kreutzmann and Lyn Anastasio (both stabbed once in the heart like the previous victim)
- March 20: Paul McConnell (attempted, but survived; was non-fatally stabbed in the chest)
- March 21: The attack at 122 Lyon Street:
- Janis Weir (attempted)
- David Rossi (attempted to stab in the neck)
- Trey has a high tolerance for pain, presumably due to his psychosis. He was able to walk barefoot on broken glass, which left deep cuts on the soles of his feet, yet this did not inhibit his ability to slaughter a couple. When he awoke the next day, he only appeared mildly irritated by the injuries. This makes Trey Gordon the fifth of only seven unsubs the BAU have apprehended that displayed a high tolerance for pain. The other six are:
- Jonny McHale ("True Night") - A serial-turned-spree killer and vigilante who withstood being hit by a car, was able to brutally slay six armed men, with one of them shooting him.
- Vincent Rowlings ("The Big Wheel") - A prolific serial killer who was shot at point-blank range by a gangbanger, yet still managed to stab him unhindered by the gunshot (but still died hours later).
- Rhett Walden ("Reflection of Desire") - A necrophiliac, abductor, and budding serial killer who was still able to carry his mother's corpse, despite being shot by Hotch at close range.
- Robert Adams "(Painless)" - An "injustice collector"-type serial-turned-spree killer, serial bomber, and copycat of Randy Slade who smashed his hand through the glass sheet of a trophy case with no visible damage, and took multiple gunshots before finally dying. Robert is also the first of these killers to have a proper medical explanation.
- Trey's was also medically explained.
- Kevin Decker ("Scarecrow") - A delusional serial killer who was stabbed in the back with shears by his last would-be victim, but still managed to remove the shears; he was also able to go after the girl, catch her and try to drown her in a trough.
- Gabriel Merza ("Blue Angel") - A serial killer and former hitman who was stabbed in the back and was still able to attack Matthew Simmons unobstructed, also not treating the stab wound at all.
- Trey has similarities to Owen Porter ("Elephant's Memory") - Both were spree killers who devolved, were abused by their fathers when they were minors, killed their victims by shooting them with rifles or by stabbing them with knives, killed one of their female victims by stabbing them repeatedly with a knife in their homes at night, and killed their first victims (who were elderly hunters in both cases) by shooting them in a forest with a rifle.
- Troy is very similar to the following unsubs on the show:
- The Footpath Killer in Season One - Both are serial killers who killed their victims in a forest by shooting them once.
- Wallace Hines in Season Nine - Both are serial-turned-spree killers who killed four of their victims by shooting them in the heart in a wooded area.
- Nathan Tubbs in Season Three - Both were spree killers who killed their victims at night by stabbing them in the heart with a knife.
- Vincent Rowlings ("The Big Wheel") - Both were serial killers with stressors involving their parents and killed their first victims by stabbing them repeatedly, then stabbed his last three victims only once.
- Ben Foster ("With Friends Like These..."), Greg Phinney ("The Stranger"), and Carl Finster ("Magnificent Light") were spree killers who killed three of their victims in their homes at night by stabbing them repeatedly.
- The Mulford Family ("Open Season") were serial killers hunted down and killed their victims in forests with long-range weaponry.
- Phillip Dowd ("L.D.S.K."), Colin Bramwell ("Final Shot"), and Zac Rubenis ("Entropy") were all at least budding serial killers who killed their victims by shooting them with rifles from long distances.
- ↑ Trey was erroneously said to be in his 20s, though judging by that birth-date, he would be 33 years old during the events of In the Dark