|Portrayed By||Gavin Rossdale|
|Appeared In||The Performer|
"You know, all I ever really wanted to do was make music, and I'm not sure when that stopped being enough."
Dante, as Paul is professionally called, is a Goth rock musician. His persona is that of a vampiric rocker, with many similarities to the portrayal of Alice Cooper by Vincent Furnier, or the character Lestat, created by Anne Rice (although Lestat is a "real" vampire in her books). He has a vast number of obsessed followers who are fanatical and willing to do whatever it takes to meet and/or please him. It is mentioned that he was arrested for domestic violence in 1999 and the charges were apparently dropped. He was also once charged with battery, but it was expunged.
Paul was considered a suspect of the murders of several fans, but it is later found out that Paul actually had nothing to do with the murders; he was only the inspiration. It is shown in the episode that Paul is an alcoholic, and possibly a drug addict (though drug use is not explicitly shown). He is an aging, washed-up rock star struggling to maintain appearances. The title of his latest album, The Liar, was etched on the arms of the victims of the episode. By the end of the episode, it is revealed that his manager Ray Campion and one of his fans Gina King were responsible for the murders. It can be assumed that the bad publicity that would ensue destroyed the reputation of Paul's Dante character.
- The song that Davies performs in the beginning of the episode is Love Will Tear Us Apart by Joy Division. Steffan Fantini, one of Criminal Minds' soundtrack composers, makes an uncredited cameo in the scene as his keyboard player/backup singer.