The BAU is called to a North Carolina resort town after a woman is found badly injured and another woman is missing. On arrival, the team discovers these two women are not the abductor's only victims. Meanwhile, Hotch is asked to coach Jack's pee-wee soccer team.
- Melissa Bickerton - Claire Proctor
- Robert Craighead - Bruce Proctor
- Caitlin Dulany - Linda Owens
- Brian F. Durkin - Officer Ted
- Andre Hotchko - Henry
- John Kapelos - Sheriff Montell
- Angie Kibiloski - Waitress
- Mandy Kowalski - Rose Bremmer
- Lennie Loftin - Don Owens
- Jeffrey Meek - Robert Bremmer
- Cade Owens - Jack Hotchner
- Michael Anthony Rawlins - Doctor Boyd
- Cody Weiant - Marcy Owens
- Jennifer Weston - Nurse
- Time Winters - Marcus Talbot
- Amanda Yarosh - Angela Proctor
- Brian David Mitchell and Wanda Ileen Barzee
- Phillip and Nancy Garrido
- "The Big Bang" by Rock Mafia
- "Gimme Some Lovin" by The Spencer Davis Group
- David Rossi: Agathon said, "Of this alone, even God is deprived, the power of making things that are past never to have been."
- Aaron Hotchner: Doménico Cieri Estrada wrote, "Bring the past only if you're going to build from it."